CHALLENGES IN DC ELECTIONS

​While DC has always been a heavily Democratic city, the party now routinely receives more than 90% of the votes in the presidential elections. In most DC races, the winner of the Democratic primary is the de facto winner of the general election, but that outcome is decided with only a small number of eligible voters participating (22.4% in the 2022 primaries) and no input from DC’s Republican or independent voters.

​

One critical exception to primaries being the key vote is DC’s At-Large races. Section 401 of the Home Rule Act (“Charter”) states that no more than two of the four At-Large seats on the Council (excluding the seat held by the Chairperson) may be of the same majority political party. As a result, DC’s elections are split with most of the races decided in the primary, and the race for the one independent seat on the Council that is elected every two years being decided in November.

​

An increased number of candidates (due in part to public campaign finance) means local officials often win their elections with a small plurality versus a majority of votes.

​

POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS

In recent years, many jurisdictions considered and implemented electoral reform, examining the rules of their political system and finding ways to ensure those rules support effective, representative government and broad democratic participation. Local electoral rules determine how officials are selected: which candidates and political parties can compete and how voters are allowed to choose between them.​

​

Nearly unlimited options for improving DC’s elections exist. Some potential options include:

• Instituting rank-choice voting.

• Holding non-partisan primaries (open primaries), with the top two (or three) finishers advancing to the general election;

• Holding runoff primary elections between the top two vote-getters if no candidate receives an absolute majority; or

• Eliminate the limitation in DC’s Home Rule Act on the number of At-Large seats that a political party may hold.

​

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?

DC Appleseed will conduct more detailed research and analysis of the selected reforms. We plan to publicly release a report on potential electoral reforms for DC in 2024.

​